Melissa McCarthy’s Hilarious Filming Challenges and Return to Stars Hollow

Chelsea Lauren/Shutterstock

Filming a beloved television series often comes with its fair share of challenges, and the iconic show “Gilmore Girls” was no exception. Actress Melissa McCarthy, known for her role as the lovable chef Sookie St. James, recently shared some amusing anecdotes about the difficulties faced on set. In an interview with Entertainment Weekly, McCarthy discussed the unexpected weather conditions, her character’s absence in the 2016 revival, and even offered a humorous glimpse into Sookie’s potential future. Let’s take a closer look at McCarthy’s behind-the-scenes experiences and her memorable return to Stars Hollow.

Filming in Hot Weather, Imagining Cold Connecticut:

While “Gilmore Girls” was set in the charming town of Stars Hollow, Connecticut, the reality of filming in sunny California posed unique challenges. McCarthy recalled moments when the cast had to endure sweltering heat while dressed in coats and attempting to portray wintry conditions. She humorously commented, “Sometimes we were, like, crammed into small things with coats on but it was actually like 112 degrees in Burbank, [California]. And we were like, ‘Brrr, Connecticut!’” McCarthy’s wit shone through as she playfully questioned the logic of her character’s perspiration-inducing appearances, jokingly linking them to Malaria.

The Uncertain Return of Sookie St. James:

Fans of “Gilmore Girls” were thrilled to learn about the 2016 Netflix revival, “Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life.” However, rumors circulated that Melissa McCarthy would not reprise her role as Sookie. McCarthy took to Twitter to express her disappointment, noting that she and her character had not been invited back to Stars Hollow. Creator Amy Sherman-Palladino confirmed that she had reached out to McCarthy’s team, but due to the actress’ busy schedule, it seemed uncertain if she could return.

A Surprise Appearance and Nostalgic Moments:

Despite initial uncertainty, Melissa McCarthy delighted fans by making a special appearance in the revival. She shared her emotional experience of returning to the set after many years, expressing her sentimentality and love for the show. McCarthy reminisced, “I went back and visited about two weeks ago and saw the sets again and everybody on them, and it just felt — oh, my God, I get so sentimental. It felt like the greatest idea in the world. It was just lovely.” Her unexpected availability allowed for a heartwarming cameo that fans cherished.

Sookie’s Imagined Future:

While Sookie’s screen time in the revival was limited to the “Fall” episode, where she created Lorelai and Luke’s wedding cake, McCarthy offered a playful insight into her character’s possible current life. In her interview with Entertainment Weekly, McCarthy humorously envisioned Sookie as a busy mother of numerous children, jokingly suggesting that she and her husband Jackson would be running a successful business specializing in delicious edibles. This lighthearted glimpse into Sookie’s hypothetical future highlighted McCarthy’s enduring love for the character and her ability to infuse humor into her portrayal.


Melissa McCarthy’s recent interview shed light on the challenges faced during the filming of “Gilmore Girls” and her eventual return to Stars Hollow. Despite the scorching California heat, McCarthy’s infectious humor and ability to find joy in the on-set struggles added a touch of levity to the production process. Fans were thrilled by her surprise appearance in the revival, and McCarthy’s musings about Sookie’s imaginary future provided an amusing update on the beloved character. Through her words, it’s evident that the spirit of “Gilmore Girls” remains alive in the hearts of both the cast and the devoted viewers who continue to cherish the show’s endearing charm.